MASTERCHEF RANT

11/16/2026

it really is unfortunate how ferociously fecal a show can get once it becomes popular and overproduced. the first four seasons of masterchef were, in joe bastianich’s words, “magnifico .” they were less drama focused and more cooking oriented. for a show called masterchef, i know, its shocking that the main focus was food

nowadays, the overproduced mess always has some new trick or gimmick to it that just takes you out of the experience. every season needs some ridiculous theme or twist when the original concept was perfectly fine as it was. you guys are looking for the best amatuer cook in america, not the best reality show contestant!

also, side tangent, i haven’t watched season 16 yet, but what’s the point of masterchef: global gauntlet? apparently, the contestants are put into groups based on their culture backgrounds, representing different regions of the world… but there are already masterchef shows all around the world. you’ve got masterchef india, masterchef australia, masterchef canada, masterchef south africa, etc. didnt the whole thing originate in the united kingdom anyway?  so what’s the point of the around the world thing?

anyway, where seasons 1 – 4 primarily excelled was having actual good cooks that you could connect to personally through their auditions. the auditions were sort of an exclusive attraction of those first four seasons, since the original format was dropped starting with season 5. now, technically, auditions came back in season 6, but instead of people individually presenting their dishes and telling their stories, they were competing in head to head battles for white aprons. later seasons continued changing the format around. so yeah, the auditions did come back, but not really in the way i liked them. and even if they do manage to recapture that original form, too bad! i’m not sitting through another seven seasons to see them

my guess is that the infamous breast milk mac and cheese incident discouraged auditions for the time being. gordon ramsay unknowingly eating a woman’s breast milk probably wasn’t what the producers had envisioned when they greenlit another season. unlesss…?

you had people with genuinely good stories behind them, and of course you had the occasional guy who was clearly just looking for their five minutes of fame. someone in season 3 even rode into the auditions on a horse, which then proceeded to take a leak all over the floor. just absolutely opened the floodgates. i felt the splashback from my bed

and just like that horse, i shed great tears down my leg thinking about how much more soulful those first four seasons were compared to the rest

but anyway, something else i came to notice was that the contestants from philly were always the most unbearable people to watch (typical). it’s unfortunate, too, because they always seemed to make it so far into the competition

take krissi from season 4, for example. me and krissi are practically neighbors, she was insufferable bruh. she had such a gross attitude

it’s pretty cool seeing what she’s up to nowadays, though, because when i checked her social media, i saw that her son was getting married. i remember during the show, when the contestants got to see their families, her son had to video call because he had his pssas. he couldn’t have been much older than middle school age. now he’s getting married!

and don’t even get me started on courtney from season 5. oh my days. slap my 🫏 with a spatula. what a soulless little souffle. she did NOT deserve to win that season. no way, no how, and wouldn’t you know it, she was from philly too.

now, something that’s always bothered me with masterchef is how often i thought the wrong person won the finale

for season 1, you had whitney miller and david miller (no relation). i remember whitney making country fried chicken while david made a beef wellington. now, a good beef wellington is always going to be a more impressive display of technical skill than a good piece of fried chicken. i mean, come on. the beef has to be cooked properly, the pastry can’t be soggy, and the whole thing has to hold together when you cut into it. it’s a pretty delicate process. whitney was making chicken. CHICKEN! like, bruh…? she won?

now, obviously there were other dishes in the finale, and i’m not saying whitney was a bad cook. i’m sure her chicken was delicious. but david made beef wellington, and i think that deserves a little more recognition than it got

season 2, i really didn’t care much about either finalist. the only person i was really rooting for was ben s. i was hoping he’d win because he had so much passion for the craft. every time he cooked, you could tell how much it meant to him. gordon even kissed him on the cheek when he was eliminated! where’s my kiss, gordon?

season 3 is where i think the chefs’ skills and personalities really shined. you had cowboy mike, the guy who rode in on the horse. he was a nice guy. you had some other pretty memorable contestants too, but the obvious standout was christine, the blind chef who went on to win the entire competition

which is just incredible. and it was completely deserved, too, in my opinion. i mean, here you have somebody competing against people who can see exactly what they’re doing, and she’s managing to cook circles around them. crazy

i think what made her so good was that she had to rely much more on tasting and smelling the food instead of looking at it. maybe having to depend so heavily on those senses helped her develop a better understanding of flavor over time. i’d imagine you’d become pretty familiar with how food should taste when you can’t really judge it by its looks

i did read that she wasn’t completely blind in the sense of seeing absolutely nothing. she described her vision as being like looking into a foggy bathroom mirror after taking a hot shower. so she could make out some light and shadows, but hardly any actual detail. imagine trying to cook a three course meal with that kind of vision, let alone doing it better than almost everybody else in the room

and the best thing about christine was that she wasn’t winning because the judges felt sorry for her. her food was actually good! she had the skill to back everything up. there was no need for some ridiculous gimmick or dramatic rivalry because just watching her cook was interesting enough. she was exactly the kind of contestant that made the earlier seasons so enjoyable

season 4, in my opinion, was the last decent season out of the bunch

you had luca returning after being rejected during the season 3 auditions, only to come back and win the entire thing

and what’s even better is that luca actually went on to do something with the title. a lot of masterchef winners seem to disappear after the show, but luca went on to pursue catering and other culinary businesses. so i think having the title of masterchef probably worked out a little more in his favor

i didn’t really like natasha, though. i thought she was conceited. just smile and wave

anyway, season 5 is where the show took a complete nosedive and became sloptent

already, there were no more traditional auditions, so that initial connection between the viewer and the contestant was gone. instead, you’re just thrown into the competition with a bunch of people you barely know. i also think the overall talent this season was weaker than what we’d seen before, although when the contestants were good, they REALLY excelled

take ahran, for example

i went into this season expecting not to like her. when i first saw her, i figured she’d be another arrogant 18 year old like max from season 2. but as i watched more and more, she actually started to grow on me. she had some pretty decent cooking skills for somebody her age, and from what i remember, she rarely missed the mark. i think she only had a few real slip ups throughout her time on the show

and her relationship with leslie was really nice to watch develop. they started off practically hating each other, but eventually they managed to put their differences aside and develop a sort of student-mentor relationship. i thought that was sweet. you could actually see their opinions of one another changing as the competition went on

and speaking of which

leslie…

leslie, leslie, leslie

the RIGHTFUL winner of masterchef season 5 in everybody’s hearts

i absolutely REFUSE to believe that man accidentally mixed up the salt and sugar in that boston cream pie. there is absolutely no way. i’m sorry. something about that whole elimination stinks worse than the horse from the auditions

earlier this season, one of the contestants, tyler, was caught accidentally taking another contestant’s panna cotta from the blast chiller and serving it as his own. the dessert actually belonged to jaimee. gordon confronted him about the mix up, and despite believing it was an honest mistake, the judges still eliminated him

now, this is a television show with cameras practically everywhere. they were able to establish whose desserts were whose, and the entire situation made for some pretty entertaining television. it was a genuinely unique incident that ended up costing somebody their place in the competition

so you’re telling me that when leslie supposedly mistakes an entire ingredient for another, nobody thought it would be interesting to show us how that happened? really?

you’re telling me that one of the strongest contestants in the competition is about to get eliminated for doing something as ridiculous as replacing sugar with salt, and we don’t get to see a single moment of him making that mistake?

i feel like that would have been incredibly engaging for the viewers to watch. just imagine the camera cutting to leslie confidently scooping a fistful of salt into his cake batter, completely unaware that he’s about to lose a quarter of a million due to such a trivial mistake.

now, you know what? fine. its completely reasonable to assume the editors simply chose not to show it. maybe they didn’t have a clear shot of the ingredients. this season’s editing wasn’t exactly the greatest anyway, so i can give them the benefit of the doubt on that one

but now let’s get into the actual science of baking

sugar doesn’t just make a cake sweet. it helps hold in the moisture, making the sponge brown, and it helps the texture and structure of the sponge itself. if you were to replace a substantial amount of it with salt, you’d expect some pretty noticeable differences in how the cake turns out. depending on how much was replaced, it could affect the pretty much everything about it

yet leslie’s cake looked perfectly fine. more than fine, actually. his looked considerably better than courtney’s, whose filling was practically leaking out of the sides like an old septic tank

now, obviously a cake can look normal and still taste like poop. i’m not saying the appearance alone proves anything. but the whole thing is still a little suspicious to me

and then there’s gordon’s reaction when he tastes it…

if i were to bite into a cake that had a bunch of salt in place of the sugar, i think my face would immediately collapse in on itself like a dying star or something. i’d be wheezing and coughing…

but gordon? he just seemed mildly concerned. sort of a “hmm, something’s not right here” expression. maybe he’s just used to downing salty cakes. i don’t know. but we’re talking about gordon ramsay here!!! the man has spent decades tasting food professionally. i’d imagine he’d have a pretty noticable reaction if somebody handed him a slice of sponge cake that tasted like a salt lamp

eventually, gordon has leslie taste his own cake and tells him that he put salt in place of the sugar. leslie even acknowledges that he may have done it

and just like that, he’s gone

the man survives 6 pressure tests, manages to make it all the way to the final three, and gets eliminated because of a supposed mix up between two white ingredients

COME ON

and you know what makes it even more infuriating? i can absolutely see the producers wanting leslie gone to make room for that stupid dramatic rivalry between courtney and elizabeth. what better way to end the season than to have these two finally face off against one another in the finale? meanwhile, leslie, the guy who’s been constantly underestimated, repeatedly thrown into pressure tests, and somehow managed to survive all of them, gets booted right before the finish. how convenient

now, do i have actual proof that the producers sabotaged leslie? no. maybe he really did mix up the ingredients. but i still don’t buy it. something about that elimination just feels wrong, and no amount of gordon ramsay telling me otherwise is going to convince me that leslie’s perfectly respectable cake was actually a giant salt lick

and then, to add insult to injury, courtney goes on to win the whole thing

bruh

anyway, i think what really happened to masterchef is that once it started getting popular, the producers realized they could squeeze more entertainment out of the contestants themselves than the actual cooking. so they started putting more emphasis on those dramatic rivalries like courtney and elizabeth

i understand that it’s a reality television show. obviously there’s going to be drama. there was drama in the first four seasons too. but at least back then, the drama felt like something happening around the cooking instead of being the entire point of the show

you had people with actual personalities and backgrounds that you could connect with. you watched them audition, you learned a little about their lives, and you got to see them improve as cooks. even the people who didn’t make it very far could still leave an impression on you

i think that’s why the first four seasons are great watches. they had a certain charm that the newer seasons i think seem to have lost. it wasn’t always about who could cause the most drama or make the biggest scene. sometimes it was just about watching a bunch of ordinary people who loved cooking get the opportunity to do something with that passion

and i thought that was pretty nice

it’s a shame, too, because i really wanted to keep watching. i was especially looking forward to season 10 because of nick digiovanni, but after witnessing the absolute travesty that was season 5, ive become completely demotivated to watch any more